Picture the Wednesday before Thanksgiving. You just landed in Denver after a flight out of KCI, the kids are running on airport pretzels and spite, and the agent at the rental counter slides a form across asking if you want the loss damage waiver, supplemental liability, personal accident coverage, and personal effects protection. There are 40 people in line behind you. You panic, initial every box, and drive off having paid for coverage you probably already owned. I’m Storm Bailey, owner of KMO Insurance Agency in Overland Park, and every December my phone fills up with clients asking whether they got fleeced at the counter. The honest answer is usually “a little,” and it’s exactly the kind of question we’d rather answer before you leave than after you get home.
You won’t be the only one standing in that line. Last year, AAA projected a record 81.8 million Americans traveling for Thanksgiving, with about 73 million going by car and roughly 6 million flying domestically. Hertz told AAA the busiest pickup day would be the Wednesday before the holiday. That’s a lot of tired people making insurance decisions in under 90 seconds. At KMO, we’d rather you make that decision at your kitchen table with one of our agents, not at a counter with a commission-earning clerk.
In most cases, yes, as long as you’re renting for personal use in the U.S. According to the Insurance Information Institute, the coverage and deductibles on your own car generally carry over to a rental you’re driving for fun rather than for business. So if your auto insurance policy includes strong liability limits plus comprehensive and collision, that protection follows you to the Phoenix airport lot. Because KMO is an independent agency, we can pull up your declarations page and tell you in about five minutes exactly what travels with you and what doesn’t.
Here’s the catch: you only bring what you have. If you dropped comprehensive and collision on your 2012 Camry to save a few bucks, the Triple-I warns you may not be covered if the rental gets damaged or stolen. Same with liability. If you’re carrying the state minimum at home, you’re carrying the state minimum in that shiny rented SUV, too. This is where we earn our keep. We work for you, not the insurance companies, so we shop multiple carriers, and putting comp and collision back on your policy may cost less for the whole year than a single week of the counter waiver.
Rental companies typically offer four products. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners, which happens to be headquartered right here in Kansas City, lays out what each one does and roughly what it costs. Our agents walk clients through this same list every holiday season so they can show up with a plan:
Loss damage waiver (LDW) or collision damage waiver (CDW): This isn’t technically insurance. It’s the rental company agreeing not to bill you if the car gets damaged or stolen, and it can also cover “loss of use” fees, towing, and administrative charges. The NAIC puts the cost at about $10 to $20 a day. The fine print matters, though, because the Triple-I notes a waiver can be voided if the damage happened while you were speeding, driving on unpaved roads, or driving impaired. If you carry comprehensive and collision at home, you likely don’t need it.
Supplemental liability: Rental companies are required to provide the state minimum liability, which the Triple-I says often isn’t enough. The add-on runs about $7 to $14 a day. If your own policy carries healthy liability limits, you can usually skip it.
Personal accident insurance: This pays medical and ambulance bills for you and your passengers, at roughly $1 to $5 a day. Between your health insurance and the personal injury protection that every Kansas auto policy is required to include, most of our clients are already covered here.
Personal effects coverage: This protects belongings stolen from the rental, typically $2 to $5 a day. Here’s the part that surprises people: your auto policy doesn’t cover the laptop stolen out of the back seat. Your homeowners or renters policy does. If you have one, you probably don’t need this.
Add those up and a family that says yes to everything could easily spend $40 a day on duplicate protection. Over a five-day Thanksgiving trip, that’s a nice dinner out, or a really impressive pie.
Maybe, but don’t bet the trip on it. Both the Triple-I and the NAIC point out that credit card rental benefits are usually secondary, which means they only kick in after your personal policy or the rental company’s coverage pays. Some cards only reimburse your deductible. Coverage also varies by card tier, so the premium card in your wallet may be far more generous than the basic one you actually used to book. If you’re counting on a card, call the issuer and ask them to send the benefits in writing. Then call us, and we’ll show you how the two fit together.
There are a few situations where saying yes at the counter makes sense:
That’s a different coverage entirely, and it trips people up every winter. If another driver caused the accident, the NAIC says their insurer should cover a rental for a reasonable repair period. If you’re filing on your own policy, though, you only get a rental if you paid for rental reimbursement, and most policies cap it with a daily and total dollar limit. Adding rental reimbursement to your car insurance coverage usually costs very little, and it’s one of the first things we check when a client’s car is about to spend two weeks waiting on parts.
The rental counter is designed to make you nervous, and nervous people buy things. The fix is simple: know what your policy covers before you’re standing under fluorescent lights with a line behind you. Call KMO Insurance Agency before your holiday trip, and we’ll tell you which counter add-ons you can confidently decline, which gaps are worth closing, and whether a few tweaks to your policy would save you money all year, not just at the airport. Whether you’re driving to Grandma’s in Wichita or flying to see family in Scottsdale, let us review your auto insurance so the only thing you’re stressing about this Thanksgiving is who gets the last slice of pie.